| 2nd Period Play-by-Play |
| | Start of 2nd period [12:00]. |
| [12:00] | Faceoff Simon Galvin vs Will O'Brien won by M, [12:00] Ground ball pickup by M Will O'Brien. |
| [11:11] | Shot by M Gabe Passini, SAVE Jack Romsos. |
| [10:46] | Clear attempt by N failed. |
| [10:44] | Turnover by N. |
| [09:42] | Turnover by M Parker Leslie. |
| [09:41] | Clear attempt by N good. |
| [09:40] | Turnover by N Brandon Price (caused by Alex Moreau). |
| [09:38] | Ground ball pickup by M Alex Moreau. |
| [09:36] | Timeout by M. |
| [09:17] | Shot by M Arjay Johnson, SAVE Jack Romsos. |
| [08:56] | Clear attempt by N good. |
| [08:23] | GOAL by N Evan Hans (FIRST GOAL). |
| Neenah 1, Middleton 0 |
| [08:23] | Faceoff Cole Fenske vs Will O'Brien won by M, [08:23] Ground ball pickup by M Alex Moreau. |
| [08:08] | Turnover by M. |
| [08:03] | Clear attempt by N good. |
| [07:24] | Turnover by N Keane Sullivan (caused by Oliver Wenning). |
| [07:13] | Ground ball pickup by M Oliver Wenning. |
| [07:11] | Clear attempt by M good. |
| [06:55] | Shot by M Gabe Passini HIT POST. |
| [06:48] | Clear attempt by N good. |
| [06:38] | Timeout by N. |
| [06:38] | Turnover by N Keane Sullivan (caused by Oliver Wenning). |
| [06:38] | Ground ball pickup by M Oliver Wenning. |
| [06:38] | Clear attempt by M good. |
| [05:45] | GOAL by M James Grosspietsch. |
| Neenah 1, Middleton 1 |
| [05:45] | Faceoff Simon Galvin vs Will O'Brien won by M, [05:45] Ground ball pickup by M Will O'Brien. |
| [05:10] | Shot by M Roan Johnson, SAVE Jack Romsos. |
| [04:58] | Clear attempt by N good. |
| [03:53] | Shot by N Owen Grotenhuis, SAVE Kyle Ballweg. |
| [03:53] | Ground ball pickup by N Keane Sullivan. |
| [03:53] | GOAL by N Keane Sullivan. |
| Neenah 2, Middleton 1 |
| [03:53] | Faceoff Cole Fenske vs Will O'Brien won by N (on faceoff violation). |
| [03:34] | Penalty on M Trey Suttle (PUSHING/0:30) Extra-man opportunity. |
| [03:00] | Turnover by N. |
| [02:36] | GOAL by M Troy Teff (MAN-DOWN). |
| Neenah 2, Middleton 2 |
| [02:36] | Faceoff Cole Fenske vs Will O'Brien won by N, [02:36] Ground ball pickup by N Ty Laabs. |
| [02:24] | Timeout by N. |
| [01:27] | Turnover by N Tate Mickelson. |
| [01:24] | Clear attempt by M good. |
| [01:15] | Timeout by M. |
| [00:49] | Turnover by M Roan Johnson (caused by Ben Carey). |
| [00:44] | Ground ball pickup by N Ben Carey. |
| [00:42] | Clear attempt by N good. |
| [00:31] | Turnover by N. |
| [00:31] | GOAL by M Gabe Passini, Assist by Roan Johnson. |
| Middleton 3, Neenah 2 |
| [00:31] | Faceoff Cole Fenske vs Will O'Brien won by M, [00:31] Ground ball pickup by M Nolan Waldorf. |
| [00:26] | Shot by M Arjay Johnson, SAVE Jack Romsos. |
| [00:20] | Clear attempt by N good. |
| [00:00] | End-of-period. |